Post-Match Review: Hull vs Arsenal (Player Ratings)

Posted: March 13, 2010 by curtisreidbarnes in Uncategorized

Arsenal draw ‘Get out of Jail Free’ card as Hull nearly burn our title chances.

A less than impressive performance from Arsenal saw them go deep into injury time equal with Hull City, before in-from Danish striker Nicklas Bendtner poached the winner to keep our title hopes alive. The Arsenal attack looked impotent after the opening goal from Andrey Arshavin, in which the Russian Maestro evaded the challenge of two Hull defenders inside the penalty error before stroking home with a classy finish. After this, Arsenal took their foot off the gas considerably, a mistake which simply cannot be made again. We almost paid very, very dearly for it. Hull’s cause was helped by some ridiculously bad decisions, the worst of which saw lumbering striker Venegoor of Hesselink’s offside go unnoticed, before he was given a penalty for throwing himself on Sol Campbell; it would be worth noting that he never even made any attempt to control the ball. Disgraceful. Boateng left the pitch in a walk of shame just before half time after a ridiculously late, high and dangerous tackle which saw him fly studs up into Bacary Sagna’s knee. Don’t tell me those sorts of tackles happening to us are just coincidence; Sagna could very easily have had his leg broken.
But thankfully, big Nicklas Bendtner was Johnny-on-the-spot for Gunners yet again, scoring his 6th goal in four games (I think…) to take his teams form to a fantastic five wins on the trot.

Despite the win, which make no mistake, was absolutely imperative, I’d like to make a few points. Firstly, what a gamble Wenger took today with his team selection. Thank goodness we haven’t been made to rue its failure. His decision to try and assert Eboue’s ability to play anywhere on the pitch clearly backfired, as, by no fault of his own, the Ivorian international was invisible for most of the game, and seemed visibly annoyed at his managers decision to play him out of position and then take him off. Eboue played right attacking midfielder in place of Walcott, who began the game on the bench. The Walcott/Eboue partnership works fantastically together and this match was tailor made for Eboue on the right flank and Walcott further ahead of him; two players whose pace, touch and ability to turn a defender would have absolutely destroyed Hull. Sagna, whilst having a very solid game on defence, looked out of place on attack, and I think many will agree it was a poor decision to play Eboue out of position…again. Why not just start Walcott ahead of him, in his natural position? It’s hard to get your head around, and it certainly didn’t pay off.

Nicklas Bendtner reignites what appeared to be the dying embers of our title bid.

We were wasteful with our chances. I bet people won’t be calling for Arshavin’s head the way they did for Bendtner’s’ after he missed all of his shots today. His finishing was the worst I have seen from him all season, even more so than the Arsenal vs. Manchester United match. We have to improve on this, as our finishing is clearly off the pace every two to three games. If we take our chances, we will do fine for the rest of the season; we are playing teams whose heads will drop once they start going 1,2,3 behind, but who will get fired up if they get a sniff. Teams like Blackburn and Spurs.

Congratulations are due to the team for the win, none the less. The difficulties of the game arose from circumstances beyond their control: Terrible officiating, over physicality bordering on the dangerous, and a ridiculous penalty. This was always going to be a very tough game, in reality. Hull have had a good home record over their last few matches at The Circle, and it took a concerted and uncompromising fight to the death to secure victory; the important thing being that it was in fact secured, so well done. Credit to Denilson for doing what we should have been doing for half an hour; shooting. It was his shot that lead to the rebound for Bendtner, and it was exactly the right thing to do.

Player Ratings:

Manuel Almunia – 7: He did absolutely everything that was asked of him today, and didn’t deserve at all to concede; even made a good go of saving the penalty, and came pretty close. He showed command of his area and dominated balls coming into the box. Definitely a strength of his. It’s also worth noting that he saved the only real shot on him during the game, a one on one with Venegoor of Hesselink. Although this was called offside, the save was a good one and he deserves credit for being on his toes.

Bacary Sagna – 7: I thought Sagna had a pretty faultless game, particularly on defence. He was very strong down his flank and didn’t allow the Hull players any space. I thought his crossing was a LOT better two; he didn’t manage to find anybody sweetly but he sent a lot of good balls in; as well as a few bad ones too. Pretty much the same as always for Bacary, great at the back, but we really saw how much we needed something to surprise the opposition when we desperately needed a goal, and he didn’t give us it.

Sol Campbell – 6.5: Suffered a harsh penalty call and an even harsher yellow card. Not a great game for him, really, and as much as I have been singing his praises he did look in serious need of a rest, even if its just a game off. Important to remember he was recovering from a serious cramp too which had kept him out of training? His match had its high points though; he matched Venegoor of Hesselink for strength and he did pretty well with aerial balls. His highlight was, for me, a brilliant and hard-hitting Tony Adams-esque tackle to dispossess Kamil Zayatte. The tackle was bone crunching but pretty fair; the tackle of an experienced and confident defender.

Thomas Vermaelen – 7.5: A pretty good game for Vermaelen, he did well in matching the physicality of the Hull City front men, who had quite clearly been sent out with instruction to try and get physical and boss the Arsenal centre-backs. Vermaelen was having none of it, and he put on a clinic at times of getting the basics right at the back; undoubtedly one of his strong points and what makes him one of the best defenders out there. He always pops up goal side of his man to make a key tackle, interception or clearance; he notably had an excellent moment at the back where he tackled Altidore before clearing acrobatically and winning the foul in the process. He is the definition of reliable and no nonsense.

Gael Clichy – 7.5: Clichy’s rich vein of form runs on and on, as he turned out another good performance, and stood out as a top performer in a team that was struggling. His defensive problems which were evident at the start of the season seem a distant memory now, and it really seems one of the strong points of his game, actually. On attack he was very good and offered pace and options in the final thirds. His crossing wasn’t as good as Sagna’s today though, so credit to Sagna for obviously working hard, as his crossing was also better in the Porto game.

Denilson – 7: It really is a story of the good, the bad and the ugly for Denilson’s game today. Let’s start with the good: he made some excellent and at times vital interceptions, and had the brains to take the shot at the end, which was the only smart thing to do at that stage of the game; pop one off and hope for a nice rebound. It paid off and he went a long way to winning us this game with that decision. Made one or two good tackles, too. I seem to remember a very good one to win possession back in Hull territory. The bad and the UGLY: His main tactic of keeping possession off a tackling player is to get smashed doff the ball and hope he gets a foul given to him. He honestly lacks so much strength; he lost the ball this way perhaps 5-10 times during the game by getting pushed off softly and appealing for a foul which was never going to be given. He needs to show a lot more spine and strength, because at the moment he is nowhere near strong or consistant enough to play defensive midfield. At heart, he still looks for fouls like an attacking midfielder.

Abou Diaby – 7.5: Was assured in possession, and very harrowing to the Hull players when they were in possession; he never gave them an inch. Showed excellent work rate in his closing down and I really think he should be the first choice replacement at defensive midfield when Song is absent. He has a much better grasp of the defensive duties of the game in the last two months. But his best work was on attack. His top quality in this game was that he seemed to be able to keep possession extremely well in tight situations. More than once he would be closely marked by one or two defenders and he found a way past them with both control and elegance several times. He helped set up a lot of attacks for us and I thought he did well. He wasn’t wasteful in possession on the flanks and didn’t fire in crappy crosses, either, opting rather to duck back inside to try and link up.

Samir Nasri – 6: Mr Invisible today, very little to say as he was he failed to make an impact to the point where he was almost just making up the numbers. Had a few moments early on where he sent some decent through balls through, one notably to Bendtner but the Dane could quite pick it up. Other than that, his passing was a fraction out and he was too closely marked to make a real difference. Substituted in the 76th minute for Eduardo, which really said a lot about how much he had struggled to create. I’m sure he will bounce back, just an off day for him.

Emmanuel Eboue – 6.5: He had some fleeting moments of great vision but nothing quite came off for him. At the risk of sounding like a broken record, I’ll repeat again that he is simply wasted when played up the pitch. He is an instinct player, not a thinker per se, and he is at his best when he simply plays the course he thinks is right when under pressure as a right back often is. A cheeky back heel pass summed up his effort, trying hard, but suffering from being out of position. Really, he should have started on the bench instead of Walcott. This was plain stupidity and stubbornness by Arsene Wenger, I’m sorry to say.

Andrey Arshavin – 7.5: Scored a great goal which proved to be very important in a tightly contested affair, but was guilty of throwing away gilt edged chances. Blazed three fantastic opportunities over the bar and realistically would feel he could have ended the day with a hat trick or more. He didn’t seem to have many opportunities to run directly at the opposing defence, as our game plan was out of tune today, though on the one chance he did get he battled his way through two defenders to score.

Nicklas Bendtner – 8 (MOTM): He had a very good game today; he played his role well and was not greedy nor wasteful with the possession he had. Scored the winner and did brilliantly to stay onside, I was biting my nails thinking he had strayed offside but he did extremely well. My only criticism is that he needs to stay around the penalty box more; too often we see him drifting out to the touch line in possession, when he is the man that we are aiming for in our play. Great to see him score again, the Christ he didn’t miss. Well done, Nik! He was delighted to score it. His was the assist too, if you forget. Really great day for him.

Theo Walcott – 8: In The brief time he had on the pitch, I think he was our best player. The moment he came on the game started to open up for us, the only problem was that by that point, most of the others were so disheartened that they couldn’t keep up with hi, so many of his crosses found no targets. He exhibited a great first touch which is exactly what a player like him needs’ a brilliant touch to make a yard of space from which to launch from. Made an instant impact and was lightening on attack, the Hull defence couldn’t handle him.

Arsenal can look forward to the return of some very welcome reinforcements next week.

The important thing is that, although the squad seems stretched and exhasuted, we got the three points, and not only that, we are coming to the end of a bad time in terms of injuries. Tomas Rosicky and Fabregas look set to return by next week, which will be a really massive lift. Alex Song’s mdifield presence will also be available following the termination of his suspension, and it desperately showed we were missing him today. We made it through, guys and girls, which is something to be proud of, and althought he win was unconvincing, the determination to achiveve it was worth the three points by itself.

Congratulations to the manager and the squad for their win today, and for making it such a dramatic one for us fans! You don’t need to do us any favours now, and comfortable 2-0 win will be just fine by me! This was a must win and although it wasn’t pretty, it wasn’t fast and it wasn’t flashy, it was three points that we can bank nonetheless.

Join me and others on the Arsenal Action Forum for all the discussion in the final run in for the season,


  1. K-TR7 says:

    We really missed little mozart today.nasri struggles away from home;rosicky/fab/both would’ve made a huge difference’s return is more than welcome.AA should spend the whole week in training practising on finishing.

  2. ThE kInG oF tHe WoRlD says:

    diaby was poor today. and denilson was.

  3. wondrinfree says:

    I think you mean Diaby ‘harried’ the Hull players, ‘harrowing’ is how they might describe the ordeal of Diaby harrying them.

  4. mikeygooner says:

    stop moaning! we won. How many times man u won the title playing poor football? We cant play n shouldnt play football champagne the whole time.

    • Curt.B says:

      Probably not worth responding to you given that you would have only read about a apragraph. if you’d read more you’d know I’m not moaning and greatly appreciate the win, but it is fair to say it was a poor perofrmance.

      Would you rather honest analysis or sugar coating?

      Your jsut the sort of person who would be bitching the most if we drew, I’m sure.

  5. Am says:

    Is Song back for WesT Ham?

  6. Dan says:

    I don’t any of us are giving enough credit for winning today.


    Gallas (starter)
    Djourou (would start if Gallas not available)

    Song (starter)
    Cesc (starter)
    Ramsey (would start if Song/Cesc not available)

    Rosicky (Starter)
    RVP (Starter)

    All 7 would have started or been starting for an injured player and we still won away from home at a team that has only lost once at home in 6 months and recently beat Man City and drew with Chelsea.

    We created 3/4 excellent chances it the 2nd half and it seemed every chance took a little bobble on the gravel pit they call a pitch and ended up 25 feet over the bar.

    We didn’t play brilliant but we deserved to win and we did win a tough match.

    • Curt.B says:

      Djourou would not start ahead of Campbell.

      And yes, your comment is correct, as I said in my article, we are suffering heavily from injuries and are coming out of a bad phase which is good.

      And yes, I havn’t claimed we didn’t deserve to win. the team that wins deserves to win.

  7. Doh says:

    Walcott 8 and Eboue not a starter!? You really are talking bollocks. Eboue understands and reads the game far better than the headless chicken Walcott. Additionally he has the ability to get past defenders without resorting to pace alone. Walcott played very well when he came on but as usual his final ball let him down. The chance to pass to nasri and the pointless cross in the box when bentdner was available pops to mind.

    • Curt.B says:

      You have missed the point; my articles have obviously gone above your head. The point is, for all the reasons you have suggested Eboue should be the starting RIGHT BACK, and not the starting RIGHT MID. If Wenger is going to play anybody at right mid, it should be Walcott, whose natural position it is. Eboue is all at sea at right mid, compared to right back. He is phenomenal at right back. You are also wrong about Walcott’s final ball, he can only do as well as his options offer, he only chose wrong once when he should have cut it back.

      You have been a bit thick and completely not understood what I was very simply saying; that if Eboue is playing right mid, he shouldn’t be starting. he should be starting at RIGHT BACK. I think I’ll refer you to my opinions on this in the article I wrote few days ago. You’ll find it if you scroll down on the blog.

      • Pat says:

        Theo’s natural position is actually CF. Personally, I think Eboue has done better at RW than Theo has this season, but thats just me.

    • Deano says:

      You, sir, are on drugs. How many shit performances from Eboue in RMF and RWF do you have to see before you come to the conclusion that he’s a RB? Have you already forgotten last season when he was murdered for each and every performance where he didn’t start in his natural position?

  8. shaun says:

    phew left it late but happy ending. absolutely made up for bendtner great to see him on the score sheet. its good to have a big target man again, i agree he should stay in the box and if he could work on striking the ball first time without trying to get it under control first like the one walcott sqared for him it was begging to be hit first time but like most arsenal players he took a touch to control it and allowed the hull defenders time to block. but that is only a slight criticism he has done brilliant since he has come back from injury and his contribution to the team has been immence if he keeps scoring at this rate adebayor will be a distant memory. yeah not at our sharpest today but would have been a travesty if we lost. arshavin should have had a hatrick. and hull created nothing untill stevie wonder fucked up twice for their goal. its also great to see arsenal are finally poping balls over the top and using walcotts devasting pace. he obviously dosnt yet have the confidence at getting the ball at his feet and taking on defenders and beating them. but with a ball over the top or slipped into space he is a joy to watch and he made a massive impact today. could do with getting his head up more often though, but a few more games like this will get his confidence back then we will start to see his true potential. i guess it just goes to show the potential of this team this was by our standards not a great performance yet we still could have won 4 or 5 nil against an in form team that is not conceding much. if this team can keep relatively injury free untill the end of the season there is no reason why we cant win the title and champions league. hope fulham do the bussiness on man utd tomoro. what would the odds be on rooney getting another goal from a free header cant remember the last time someone put a challenge in on him.

  9. Deano says:

    Bendtner still needs three touches from eight yards, which is bugger, but he was there when it mattered!

    Good stuff.

  10. Bayonne Jean says:

    Even though it was obvious how much Cesc was missed in this match, for West Ham at Emirates, do you think it would be wise to hold him out of starting 11 and only sub him in if needed? My view is that we need a fully fit #4 for the run-ins, and with Song back and Nasri given a week’s rest and his much superior form at the Emirates, we could rest Cesc. again Also have Old Sol take an R&R week.

    • Curt.B says:

      I wouldn’t be surprised if Fabregas starts the game from the bench, to be honest. I think we will see the same formation except probably Eboue at RB and Walcott starting, with Sagna dropping to the Bench as Wenger likes to play Eboue at the Emirates, and he will terrify a team like West Ham.

      I think Wenger might consider starting Rosicky, ahead of Nasri, depending on fitness.

      Otherwise I think you will see a very similar team, with another possiblity of Campbell having a rest and being replaced by Song or Silvestre.

  11. ewan says:

    To win the league, it is essential that Fabregas and Gallas come back into the run in. Song’s back and that will help.

    • Curt.B says:

      Yes having back too such fantastic players will be a great help. They are both crucial. We need Gallas back as soon as possible; Campbell is doing a great job but he can’t play week in week out. Wouldn’t be surprised if Silvestre starts against West Hamm or Song at CB with Denilson at DM.

  12. Gooner from Sydney says:

    This is exactly what we need, even when we didnt play good, we still won, albeit a bit nervy.

    The biggest victim here is Sinbad, poor bloke was 3 minutes away from his first article in weeks

  13. Fredwest says:

    Denilson was shit mate

  14. Dan says:

    Where’s that petition fellas?

  15. GunnerPete says:

    Your grudging praise for AW & the team was welcome but a sad enditement of your bias as was the attack on Eboue who always gives 100% where ever he is played. The team almost picked itself after a midweek game ANd so many missing stars….I would love to see Manure or Chelski win these games without 5 of their TOP stars. manure especially without Rooney. I was impressed with the team balance and the fight for 96mins. I was unimpressed with the ESPN commentary’Champion’ is very poor and biased. Keegan was just full of Yorkshire bias and lack of eyesight when saying the penalty was a goalscoring op?? even Henry has never scored a goal from behind his head!

    The Hull fans along with most Northern fans show a lack of football knowledge..they spend most of the game cheering fouls and booing the fouled. They accuse AFC of cheating but call handball for every chested ball and sometimes for a headed clearance. They applaud aplayer sent off for a knee high challenge and praise him when he gets Bentner carded for reacting after being rugby tackled then had fingers in his eyes? Worst still there manager has never learned to tape up his mouth immediately after any game…it is open just long enough to make him and their club look even more stupid than they look on the pitch.

    Arsene we will one day get an apology from these tarts who demand your sacking… and one day they will wake up and see where you have taken us yet again without bankrupting the club.

    • Curt.B says:

      There is nothing grudging about my praise, I assure you.

      As for Eboue? You clearly don’t know my opinions on him, I suggest yu scroll down the blog and have a read. He is probably my favourite player.

      Can’t you see how thick you are being, not to understand? ‘Eboue always gives 100 percent’: EXACTLY! thats the point. He is great and should be playing right back, not right mid.

      Man, its getting fucking dull trying to get this simple point through to some of you guys.

      Try READING before you make a comment…

      • Curt.B says:

        Oh, and stop being a Wenger hater, you dumb bastard.

        Feel hard done by being called this, maybe because you actually don’t hate Wenger in the slightest?

        Now you know how I feel having to read the shite that comes from people like you.

  16. KING GOONER says:

    i thought setanta was bad when it came to anti-arsenal bias but espn & that c**t jon champion have brought it to another level-he was deermined to see big sol off the pitch no matter what-thank f**k he wsan’t reffing-bet he was gutted at the death though lol!

    • Curt.B says:

      Mate I heard from somebody watching the ESPN coverage that they were absolutely shocking, especially over claims that campbell should have seen red.

  17. […] Post-Match Review: Hull vs Arsenal (Player Ratings) Arsenal draw ‘Get out of Jail Free’ card as Hull nearly burn our title chances. A less than impressive performance […] […]

  18. saminator says:

    to be fair, arsenal actually played well, the win to show for it. the problem was not how we played but how we were played against and how the ref tended to handle the game.
    also i suggest that cesc is rested for the west ham game. i know it’s a derby but remember it’s a home game and west ham are not really the west ham of the previous seasons. we need cesc for the more serious games like birmngham after, spurs and mancity. and i agree with mikeygooner, winning cannot and should not be only from playing pretty. you will not always be at yout best week in week out. what matters at the end of the day are the three points.

  19. JSP says:

    Gouging carries a really long ban in Rugby, and what that twat Boteng did on Saturday was just the same. I hope the FA don’t hide behind the ref saw it crap and ban this tosser forever!!!

  20. panda says:

    omg an 8 for a tap in off a retard denilson shot
    -keeper should have saved both

    if NB is an 8 – drogba and rooney must score like 25 out of ten sometimes

    im glad hes scoring hope he can keep it up but tap ins- come on!

    • Curt.B says:

      Your an idiot. Do you even read or just see a number and type? Read what comes after the 8 and you will see reasons for the 8.

      Sometimes blogging feels like being a kindergarten teacher, honestly.

  21. Goonerman says:

    ESPN are amateurs, they do not know the game. KKeegan’s judgement is suspect. Joe royle is the only one sensible on that programme.

  22. ooooh aaaah Eboue says:

    Has Sinbad committed suicide yet? Or has he gone on holiday with Myles Palmer and a jar of viagra for a bit of shit -digging?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s